Li XS, Zheng WY, Lou SX, Lu XW, Ye SH. Effect of ginkgo leaf extract on vascular endothelial function in patients with early stage diabetic nephropathy. Chin J Integr Med. February 2009;15(1); 26-29.
A common
complication of diabetes is a type of kidney damage known as diabetic nephropathy.
Impaired function of the endothelium, the inner lining of blood vessels, may play
an important role in the development of diabetic nephropathy. Extracts of ginkgo
(Ginkgo biloba) leaves have
antioxidant and anti-platelet effects and are used to improve blood flow in a
number of conditions. Studies in animals and humans with diabetes suggest that
ginkgo can improve symptoms of diabetic nephropathy. The purpose of this trial
was to evaluate the effects of ginkgo on vascular endothelial function in
people with early stage diabetic nephropathy.
People with
type 2 diabetes were eligible if they had diabetic nephropathy that was
classified as early stage. Pregnant or breastfeeding women and people with liver
disease, psychiatric diseases, or other kidney diseases were excluded from the
trial. All subjects were treated with standard medical care, which included
diabetic education, a low protein diet, and medications to control blood
glucose levels and high blood pressure. This randomized trial was conducted at
Jinhua College of Profession and Technology in
A total of
64 subjects were randomly allocated to 2 groups. Subjects in the control group
continued on with standard medical care only. Subjects in the ginkgo group received
standard medical care plus 3 tablets daily of ginkgo leaf extract (Tianbaoning;
Kang’enbei Pharmaceutical Company;
The study
lasted for 8 weeks. Urine tests, blood tests, and ultrasound scans of the
brachial artery were performed at baseline and at the end of the 8-week period.
The blood tests measured glucose, creatinine (a measure of kidney function),
and markers of endothelial function. These markers were von Willebrand factor,
which promotes blood clotting; nitric oxide, which promotes dilation of blood
vessels; and endothelin-1, which promotes constriction of blood vessels. The
urine test evaluated urinary excretion of albumin. The brachial artery
ultrasound scans were used to assess endothelial function. The inner diameter
of the brachial artery, the major blood vessel in the arm, was measured before
and after inflation of a pressure cuff (endothelium-dependent dilation) and before
and after oral nitroglycerin (endothelium-independent dilation).
At
baseline, there were no significant differences between the 2 groups for age, gender,
years of diabetes, or body mass index. The mean age of subjects was 67 years and
the mean duration of diabetes was 8 years. The authors do not report how many
subjects in each group completed the 8-week trial, so it is not clear if the
analysis includes data from all 64 subjects who were enrolled.
Creatinine
levels and urinary excretion of albumin decreased significantly (both P < 0.01)
in the ginkgo group but not in the control group after 8 weeks. Nitric oxide
increased significantly (P < 0.01) and von Willebrand factor decreased
significantly (P < 0.01) in the ginkgo group but not in the control group. As
the von Willebrand factor was abnormally high in both groups at baseline, the
decrease in the ginkgo group means that normalization of this factor can be achieved
by this ginkgo extract. Fasting blood glucose and endothelin-1 levels did not
change significantly in either group. The increase in brachial artery diameter after
inflation of the pressure cuff was significant (P < 0.05) for the ginkgo
group, but not for the control group. There was no significant difference
between the groups for the increase in brachial artery diameter following the
nitroglycerin challenge.
In this
study, ginkgo had a protective effect on vascular endothelial function in
people with early stage diabetic nephropathy. Eight-week treatment with ginkgo
improved kidney function markers, endothelial function markers, and endothelium-dependent
dilation as assessed by ultrasound. The authors suggest that adding ginkgo to
standard medical care may be helpful in delaying the development of nephropathy
in people with early stage diabetic nephropathy.
The authors
point out that a previous study reported a decrease in endothelin-1 in people
with diabetic nephropathy following treatment with ginkgo, but this study found
no change in endothelin-1. This could be due to differences in the ginkgo
product, ginkgo dose, or method for determining endothelin-1 between the 2
studies.
The authors
do not discuss any limitations of this trial, nor do they report any adverse side
effects associated with ginkgo use. Diabetes is a chronic, progressive
condition, and long-term trials are needed to evaluate the clinical
significance, safety, and effectiveness of ginkgo in people with diabetic
nephropathy.